math：给几个演奏家排个名

    塞戈维亚 布利姆 威廉斯 大为 叶佩斯 佩佩 山下河人 巴鲁埃克

我的排名
塞戈维亚 布利姆 佩佩 大为 威廉斯 叶佩斯 山下河人

巴鲁埃克我不熟悉没有排
叶佩斯很有个性，但是我受不了，太硬
山下河人除了技术还有什么？
威廉斯实在不敢恭维，太平淡，几乎所有的曲子在他手里都是白开水
大为很纯，气质很好
佩佩了不起
布利姆个性极强，气质极好
塞戈维亚当然是老大

本贴由math于2002年5月17日19:06:54在乐趣园〖古典吉他村论坛〗发表.

leetrue：disagree

    It is absolutely not erery one who can arrange the series of the master of guitar.

本贴由leetrue于2002年5月17日22:10:04在乐趣园〖古典吉他村论坛〗发表.

快乐的铁匠：谁敢给大师排位置？

    在我的眼中，这些大师都是神，听他们出神入画的演奏，只能说他们代表了各种流派，各种风格。谁敢给他们分出个1234。

本贴由快乐的铁匠于2002年5月18日01:13:55在乐趣园〖古典吉他村论坛〗发表.

lyangmao：不敢拍名，只是说说自己最喜欢的吧

    Segovia, Pepe, Julian Bream, Parkening

每一位都有自己的特点和过人之处。或许我们可以搞一个投票活动，评选自己最喜欢的吉他演奏家。不知大家意下如何？

本贴由lyangmao于2002年5月18日09:55:29在乐趣园〖古典吉他村论坛〗发表.

leetrue：can you play chaconne?

    It’s absolutely not everyone who can arrange the series of the masters of the guitar. Music is not the skill. So far as the skill is concerned, except that Japanese player, you cannot tell out who is the best, but only Fernandez can play the guitar wonderfully without any cacophony. In the case of music, if we don’t take Segovia into account, no one is better than Williams. Williams can play every song perfectly. Every one when he has played guitar at least for 10 years constantly must think so, especially when he can play chaconne. I disagree absolutely that the music played by Williams, whom many great guitarists (including David and the two greatest Chinese guitarists Dengming Ye and Xuefei Yang) thought the greatest guitar master alive, is just like drinking the white boiled water. Was Bach the greatest musician in the history? No one has the qualification to doubt this, but not every one likes his music, because someone thought his music is too abstract and mild and lacks furor, but his music is the most wonderful and beautiful. Williams’s music is the same. His music is of profundity and artistry and his tone color of guitar is elegant. When compared with Williams, Pepe Romero’s guitar solo is superficial and his tone color of guitar is thin but clangorous. Maybe sonorousness and enthusiasm are strongpoint. Of cause, Pepe Romero is one of the greatest guitarists.

本贴由leetrue于2002年5月18日12:35:52在乐趣园〖古典吉他村论坛〗发表.

leetrue：williams

    It’s absolutely not everyone who can arrange the
series of the masters of the guitar. Music is not the
skill. So far as the skill is concerned, except that
Japanese player, you cannot tell out who is the best,
but only Fernandez can play the guitar wonderfully
without any cacophony. In the case of music, if we
don’t take Segovia into account, no one is better
than Williams. Williams can play every song perfectly.
Every one when he has played guitar at least for 10
years constantly must think so, especially when he can play chaconne.
I disagree absolutely that the music played by
Williams, whom many great guitarists (including David
and the two greatest Chinese guitarists Dengming Ye and Xuefei Yang) thought the greatest guitar master alive, is just like drinking the white boiled water.
Was Bach the greatest musician in the history?
No one has the qualification to doubt this, but not
every one likes his music, because someone thought
his music is too abstract and mild and lacks furor,
but his music is the most wonderful and beautiful.
Williams’s music is the same. His music is of
profundity and artistry and his tone color of guitar
is elegant. When compared with Williams, Pepe Romero’s guitar solo is superficial and his tone color of guitar is thin but clangorous.
Maybe sonorousness and enthusiasm are his strongpoint.
Of cause, Pepe Romero is one of the greatest guitarists.

本贴由leetrue于2002年5月18日12:49:22在乐趣园〖古典吉他村论坛〗发表.

leetrue：Williams

    It’s absolutely not everyone who can arrange the series of the masters of the guitar.
Music is not the skill. So far as the skill is concerned, except that Japanese player, you cannot tell out who is the best,
but only Fernandez can play the guitar wonderfully without any cacophony.
In the case of music, if we don’t take Segovia into account, no one is better than Williams.
Williams can play every song perfectly.
Every one when he has played guitar at least for 10 years constantly must think so,
especially when he can play chaconne.
I disagree absolutely that the music played by Williams, whom many great guitarists
(including David and the two greatest Chinese guitarists Dengming Ye and Xuefei Yang)
thought the greatest guitar master alive,
is just like drinking the white boiled water.
Was Bach the greatest musician in the history?
No one has the qualification to doubt this,
but not every one likes his music,
because someone thought his music is too abstract and mild and lacks furor,
but his music is the most wonderful and beautiful.
Williams’s music is the same.
His music is of profundity and artistry and his tone color of guitar is elegant.
When compared with Williams,
Pepe Romero’s guitar solo is superficial and his tone color of guitar is thin but clangorous.
Maybe sonorousness and enthusiasm are his strongpoint.
Of cause, Pepe Romero is one of the greatest guitarists.

本贴由leetrue于2002年5月18日12:53:15在乐趣园〖古典吉他村论坛〗发表.

math：有道理

    但是我还是不能接受williams无论如何也不能
他虽然什么都能弹，但是都很平常

本贴由math于2002年5月19日16:39:03在乐趣园〖古典吉他村论坛〗发表.

guitar：hi there

    I've read your statement about the question of arranging the series of the masters, especially your comment on John, my idol, whom I've met twice in China and Australia.

I can feel that you know the guitar well. Can we share the joy of the art of guitar? Contact me!
OICQ; 2015465
e-mail: savarez@sina.com

I hope to hear from you soon!

本贴由guitar于2002年5月21日00:26:59在乐趣园〖古典吉他村论坛〗发表.

sammer：其实我觉得没太大必要

    我最喜欢williams，但是觉得bream、山下也都是非常优秀的。这些东西一个人一种说法：）

本贴由sammer于2002年5月23日16:45:22在乐趣园〖古典吉他村论坛〗发表.

leetrue：Don't take it seriously.

    If let me rank them, the series is:
Segovia, Williams, Frrnandez, Parkening, David, Bream, Romero, Yepes. They are all the greatest guitarists.

本贴由leetrue于2002年5月23日21:44:23在乐趣园〖古典吉他村论坛〗发表.